- We open on a little boy's bedroom where the kid in question is playing with his toys. He's moving them around and doing all their voices as he plays.
- There's a whole town he's set up made out of cardboard boxes with a wanted poster featuring a mean-looking Mr. Potato Head doll. Dum dum dumm.
- Suddenly, the Mr. Potato Head doll jumps into view and points a (toy) gun at some other toys and demands they open the safe (an adorable pink piggy bank) for him. Egads!
- The other toys are frightened and when a Little Bo Peep figure tries to stand up to the Mr. Potato Head, he threatens to kill her sheep. Can't anyone save them?
- Enter one Sheriff Woody. The boy tugs on Woody's pull cord and the cowboy tells Mr. Potato Head (also known as One-Eyed Bart) to "reach for the sky!"
- Just then, Mr. Potato Head brings out his attack dog with a built-in force field.
- Luckily, Woody has also remembered to bring his dinosaur who eats force field dogs. Touché, Sheriff Woody.
- Sheriff Woody apprehends the villainous Mr. Potato Head and throws him right into jail…otherwise known as the baby crib.
- The baby inside picks up the toy, drools on him a little, then smashes his head on the railing.
- All in a day's work for Sheriff Woody.