ShmoopTube
Where Monty Python meets your 10th grade teacher.
Search Thousands of Shmoop Videos
Justice and Judgement Videos 20 videos
It may be the best of times for Chuck Darnay, but it's pretty much constantly the worst of times for Sydney. Poor guy.
Historical fiction novels like The Help can whisk you back to a place and time that you may have only read about in history books. Or... a place an...
Crime and Punishment is all about a boy killing for money, literally, and then spending the rest of the book trying to hide it. Although the book c...
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 2843 Views
Share It!
Description:
Lisbeth Salander is a tough nut to crack. Hero? Villain? Somewhere in the middle? We're not sure, but we're hesitant to accuse her of anything...especially after what she did to the last guy.
Transcript
- 00:05
The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, a la Shmoop. We all know what heroes are supposed to look
- 00:14
like in fiction. They fly through the air...
- 00:17
...or shoot arrows and catch fire...
- 00:18
...or take out He Who Should Not Be Named.
- 00:20
But what if a character's behavior makes it tough to tell if he or she is a hero?
Full Transcript
- 00:28
In Stieg Larsson's book, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo...
- 00:34
...disgraced journalist Mikael Blomkvist <<meh-kale bloam-quist>> and troubled computer hacker
- 00:38
Lisbeth Salander <<liz-bith sal-in-der>> join forces to find a girl who went missing decades
- 00:43
ago...
- 00:43
...and end up on the trail of a serial killer.
- 00:47
Uh, wrong kind of cereal. While on the quest to find the missing girl,
- 00:55
Lisbeth shows that not only is she a brilliant researcher...
- 00:58
...but she also has a gift for using violence to get what she wants...
- 01:02
...which leads us to the question: Should Lisbeth be considered a hero?
- 01:13
While the abuse inflicted on her by her guardian was terrible, Lisbeth's decision to take the
- 01:19
law into her hands...
- 01:20
...in a very creative way...
- 01:22
...shows us that she's a ruthless individual.
- 01:32
Wouldn't a true hero use legal means to punish a rapist, rather than Lisbeth's more brutal
- 01:38
methods? Okay, so it's true that Lisbeth is violent
- 01:38
and willing to resort to criminal behavior in order to achieve her goals...
- 01:40
...but she also demands justice for herself and helps those she cares about.
- 01:46
Doesn't saving Blomkvist from death at the hands of a serial killer count as heroism?
- 01:51
If Blomkvist hadn't had Lisbeth's assistance, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo would have
- 01:53
had a very different ending.
- 01:56
When all's said and done, it's really Lisbeth who saves the day.
- 01:59
So, which is it?
- 02:02
Should Lisbeth be excluded from hero-dom because she violently metes out punishment herself
- 02:09
rather than leaving it to the authorities?
- 02:14
Does she occupy a gray area, where some of her actions are heroic, but not others?
- 02:21
Or is Lisbeth the real hero of The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, because the good things
- 02:23
that happen in the book happen because of her?
- 02:27
Shmoop amongst yourselves.
Related Videos
They say that honesty is the best policy, but Jack lies about his identity and still gets the girl. Does that mean we should all lie to get what we...
Ever wish you could remember everything that you ever studied? How about everything that everyone has ever studied? Yeah, pretty sure our brains ju...
Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man is an American classic. Hope you're not expecting any exciting shower scenes though. It's not that kind of book.
Do not go gentle into that good night. In fact, if it's past your curfew, don't go at all into that good night. You just stay in your good bed and...
