A Crust For the Critics
- In the first chapter of Book 10, you might have thought the narrator was being a little harsh with the critics.
- He wants to take this chapter to explain why they deserve it.
- The word "critic" means to give judgment.
- Some critics seem to think that this means legal judgment, because they often condemn other people's works without mercy.
- But you know what the narrator thinks? He thinks these critics are just "common [slanderers]" (11.1.5). (A slanderer is someone who spreads false statements about someone else.)
- After all, they can ruin an author's reputation forever, without there being any way for the author to fight back.
- Worst of all, these attacks are often completely unprovoked and pointless.
- They are just mean for the sake of being mean.
- And it's not just a matter of emotional investment.
- A book also represents a big financial payoff for the author.
- When a critic kills off an author's book, he is hitting that author right in the wallet.
- Last but not least, when a critic insults a book, he is also insulting the author personally.
- Nobody can call a book stupid without meaning to say that the author is also a fool.
- Here are some signs that you might be a bad critic:
- (1) If you criticize books you have not read, you might be a bad critic.
- (2) If you say a whole book is "vile, dull [… or] low" (11.1.16) without giving any specific reasons, you might be a bad critic.
- (3) Let's say a book has some less good bits, but it's excellent overall.
- If you say that book is entirely bad, just because of those few flaws, you might be a bad critic.